Description
This is the second of 5 evening talks which Jay gave at the famous Kensington Temple in central London, between March 2 - 7, 2026.
You can see all of these talks on the KT site at: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCSMYJ-9nYRpzqYlThAXnrZg
This second video Jay compares the model for Christianity, Jesus Christ, against the model for Islam, Muhammad, and asks which is more relevant for today, but also which is more historical.
With this latter question, Jay introduces some new and very damaging research into what we now know concerning how the story of Muhammad as actually passed down to us today.
When compared to the historical authority for Jesus, there is just no comparison.
Below is the outline of the areas Jay covers in this video:
An outline of the areas Jay will be covering are:
INTRODUCTION
[I] JESUS IN THE QUR’AN: Even in the Qur'an Jesus is superior to Muhammad
[II] WAS MUHAMMAD A ‘MAN OF PEACE’?: When you look at the record from the Islamic Traditions, he was a man of violence, and not a man of peace.
[III] WAS JESUS A ‘MAN OF PEACE’?: In contrast to Muhammad, and in fact to any other great leader, Jesus turns out to indeed be a true 'Man of Peace'!
[IV] A SUPPOSED PROBLEM WITH JESUS: Looking at the major questions Muslims pose against Jesus and answering them in 2 minutes.
[V] COMPARING JESUS AND MUHAMMAD: When compared to Muhammad Jesus comes out on top every time.
[VI] THE HISTORICAL JESUS: Historical speaking, the Bible has the right Jesus doing the right things at the right time, proving he really has an amazing historical record.
[VII] THE HISTORICAL MUHAMMAD: New research shows how we know almost nothing about the Muhammad of Islam as we simply have no records of what he said or did for between 400 - 800 years after he died!
This suggests that the Muhammad of the Traditions (i.e. the Standard Islamic Narrative), and the man Muslims follow today, is not the 'Muhammad of History', but simply the 'Muhammad of faith'!
CONCLUSIONS
© Pfander Centre for Apologetics & Polemics - US, June 27, 2026
(132,000)